Smart Materials in 4D Printing: Transformative Technologies for Adaptive Solutions in pharmacy

Abstract

The pharmaceutical industry will witness revolution with the introduction of 4D printing that introduces smart materials capable of change in shape and properties when subjected to certain external stimuli in respect to enhancing drug delivery systems as well as personalized medicines. The technology will be able to produce dynamic pharmaceutical products that respond to patients' physiological conditions for controlled responsive drug release. For example, 4D-printed drug delivery systems can be designed to release in response to specific triggers of pH changes or temperature variance within the body, thereby enhancing therapeutic efficacy and patient compliance. Moreover, 4D printing has made it possible to create a variety of personalized implants and medical devices that fit the anatomy of different individuals without requiring invasive procedures. These advances are based on the core use of stimulus-sensitive materials such as shape memory polymers and hydrogels. However, the utility of 4D printing within pharmacy is plagued by material selection, regulatory hurdles, and several more direct steps required in translation from laboratory successes to clinical applications. This abstract clearly identifies 4D printing with smart materials as a transformational approach to adaptive pharmaceutical solutions that will pave the way to future innovations in healthcare.

Keywords

4D,Printing, Smart materials, Technology,Healthcare,Future

Introduction

Some of the sectors that have significantly transformed, following the introduction of 3D printers, are healthcare and pharma. Due to the capacity of 3D printing to quickly build very complex and customized structures, the game of several businesses is made different. While high performance demands of 3D printing can easily achieve very complex static objects, there are gaps—with respect to both functional complexity and dynamic adaptability—that the second scenario highlights, ’akin to behaviours that can change over time adaptively, similar to biological tissues. Due to this constraint, 4D printing—an innovative form of 3D printing where the  addition of time as a new dimension has been incorporated—has become a niche market. Smart materials are  used in 4D printing which are capable of responding to stimuli such as light, temperature, humidity  and pH level to change their form, properties or functions. This ability for active tuning presents possibilities for  the development of the state of the art pharmaceuticals and device concepts that are compatible with the individual  patient’s needs.[1-4]

4D printing is based on what are called ‘smart materials’ which can be grouped depending on  their response to changes in environment. Among these, Shape Memory Polymers (SMPs)  have been studied most intensively by scientists. Such materials have the feature of going back to a predetermined  shape when exposed to certain triggers like heat which or has light. the Hydrogels ability is to another take type in of large smart amounts material of  water and expand or contract depending on the amount of  moisture in the environment. These new materials will be used in the creation of smart drug delivery systems and  personalized medical instruments which are capable of adjusting their shape based on the patient’s physical parameters.[5,6]

By incorporating these materials with 4D printing it is possible to fabricate objects that have the  capacity to meet the dynamic or changing constraints which classical medicines would meet. Such drug delivery systems that are  capable of releasing the drugs in a controlled manner and at a specific time when the drug is exposed to  certain conditions such as change in temperature in the body or change in pH in the gastrointestinal tract; this  ensures that the medicine is released at the right time.[7-9]4D printing has a lot of potentials in pharmaceutical industry. The largest fragmentation is seen in the drug delivery systems. Here bad bioavailability is faced as same problem with patient compliance due to traditional methods. Researchers can then use the design of responsive drug formulations based on the technology of 4D printing which can change their release profiles according to real-time physiological parameter.[10,11]

In order to reduce the side effects; hydrogel based tablets can be created where it would only swell and start to release the drug to interact from certain pH levels for the purpose of localized therapy when the neighbouring charged becomes acceptable, so that it will not cause much of the impact on other parts/ organs of body. Apart from drug delivery applications, it is evident from various studies that personalized medicines also receive a huge advantage from 4D bioprinting.[12-14]

If patient-specific implants and prosthetics closely match individual patient anatomy, the effectiveness of the treatment could be significantly enhanced. I. For instance, a patient’s bone structure will change over time after orthopaedic surgery, if we can construct the implants by 4D printing, this is better for the whole patient and less need for the patient to undergo additional surgery.[15,16]

Another big aerospace 4D printing space in pharmaceuticals is the ‘tissue engineering’ side – here the aim is to effectively engineer constructs that bond living cells with smart materials that can grow into, or seamlessly replace/overlap existing native tissues in human being; it will have impressive implications on regenerative medicine. However, achieving these potential benefits of 4D printing in pharmaceuticals faces multiple challenges and a few bottlenecks. For example: designing smart materials that are able to respond consistently and reliably under physiological conditions is far from easy.[17-19]

Moreover, these technologies are quite new, and thus their clinical application has been restricted, largely due to the lack of adequate regulatory frameworks. In addition, while 4D printing studies are emergent, most implementations are only experimental and not ready for clinical applications. A real existing technology with the proper extent of testing and validating the newly developed materials to prove safe and efficient will be the final goal.[20,21]

Future works should also focus on developing materials with more superior mechanical properties as well as new designs based on the potential advantages offered by 4D printing. In order to accelerate the introduction of these new technologies from academic lab settings into real health care delivery systems that benefit patients there must be collaboration between academia and industry, among national regulatory bodies fostering global harmonization in regulation policies34. Consequently 4D printing will cause a revolution within both pharmaceutical science and the field of medicine with broad implications.[22]

2.Smart Materials in Pharmacy

Particularly since the introduction of 4D printing, smart materials have been at the forefront of the development of medication delivery systems. To provide precise control over medication release and improve therapeutic efficacy, these smart materials react dynamically to any stimulus, including pH levels, temperature, light, and biological signals. These are some characteristics of smart materials that are pertinent to medication delivery.[23]pH Sensitivity :Drug delivery applications where the local environment can significantly impact the solubility and stability of pharmaceuticals benefit greatly from the use of pH-sensitive smart materials. These substances can release medications at specific locations inside the body and may alter their solubility or structure in response to pH changes. For instance, hydrogels based on poly(acrylic acid) or chitosan swell at physiological pH levels, allowing the regulated release of the medications they contain when the pH changes in the tumor microenvironment or the gastrointestinal tract.Response to Temperature :Temperature-sensitive materials react to temperature changes by changing their physical characteristics. Drug delivery systems that require activation at a certain time to release medications make use of this characteristic. For example, the well-known thermoresponsive polymer poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm) experiences a phase shift at body temperature. Systems that release medications when they reach a specific temperature can be created by taking advantage of this trait, which makes them beneficial for uses like treating cancer by localized hyperthermia. [24,25]

3. Sensitivity to Light  :Light-sensitive smart materials undergo photochemical reactions that alter their structure or characteristics in response to particular light wavelengths. Because of this property, drug distribution can be controlled non-invasively in both space and time. For instance, light-sensitive nanoparticles that release therapeutic compounds in response to tissue-penetrating near-infrared (NIR) light can be created. This strategy holds great promise for targeted cancer treatments, as localized care can reduce harm to nearby healthy tissues.

4. Responsiveness to Biological Signals :One of the most innovative approaches to medication delivery systems is the use of smart materials that react to biological signals, such as enzymes or certain proteins. When specific enzymes that are overexpressed in some disorders (like cancer) are present, these materials can be designed to release medications. For example, in the presence of particular proteases present in tumor microenvironments, enzyme-sensitive polymers may break down and release their payload. Because it guarantees that medications are released just at the intended locations and minimizes adverse effects from systemic activity, this sensitivity raises the therapeutic index. [26-28]With the aid of targeted and controlled release, the integration of smart material into drug delivery system can yield out-standing therapeutic advantages. The sensitivity to pH, temperature, light and bio environments of these materials assist in designing sophisticated drug  delivery systems that allow better controlling on drug release weapon for patient adherence improvement.[29]

3.Applications in Pharmacy

Drug delivery systems are being revolutionized with the advent of 4D printing while its use also allows development of personalized medicine and dynamic devices that can act according to the physiological conditions. For this smart materials are utilized for printing purpose which are programmed to transform their properties according to different type stimuli which leads to most efficient, cost effective and personalized treatment approaches. Below we have mentioned few applications of 4D printing in pharmacy:[30]

1.Personalized Medicine:

4D-printed drug pills, can easily release the drugs they contain at specific times or in specific quantities as required by each patient. They do so by incorporating the kind of smart materials that react to a given physical state like temperature or pH that is characteristic for example of a physiological condition. The likelihood for optimal therapeutic benefit and drug effect increases when patients comply completely with their prescribed medications. Indeed, a 4D-printed drug pill designed as an expandable hydrogel capsule for instance would not release its content until it reaches he stomach which has an acidic environment. A degree of tailored care that is tailored to the patient's circumstances and way of life in order to achieve the best possible therapeutic results and compliance.[31,32]

2. Dynamic Drug Delivery using Implantable Devices

One of the most promising applications of 4D printing in pharmacy is the development of  implantable devices with the ability to dynamically administer drugs. They can be made to change their shape or drug release profile when the environment surrounding the body changes. A 4D printed implant, for example, could expand or contract upon detection of some biological marker or change in temperature, enabling regulated slow release of therapeutic agents. This adaptivity reduces intervention frequency and increases patient compliance and is particularly useful for chronic diseases requiring life-long pharmaceutical treatment.[33]

3.Systems for Bio responsive Drug Delivery

One of the most promising applications of 4D printing in medicine is the bio-responsive drug systems, which make use of smart materials that respond to specific biological signals, such as changes in pH or enzyme levels. For example, if certain enzymes are overproduced at a tumor site, an enzyme-sensitive polymer can be designed to release drugs only at the desired location within the body. As an innovative and precise treatment option for cancer therapy or other diseases with targetable sites without risk of systemic toxicity this has gained interest.[34]

4.Pharmaceutical Adaptive Packaging and Logistics

Apart from direct drug delivery purposes, 4D printing technique supplies a new manner to achieve flexible packaging and logistics for pharmaceutical applications as well. Smart packaging may dynamically change its properties via responding to external stimuli (e.g., temperature or humidity) for providing the optimal storage environment for fragile pharmaceuticals. For example, moisture-sensing packaging, which releases desiccants when the humidity increases, could help stabilize hygroscopic drugs. In addition, real-time monitoring of drug conditions during transportation might be realized by adaptive logistics technologies to ensure efficient and safe distribution of prescription medicines.                            With its revolutionary solutions for personalized medicine, dynamic drug delivery systems, bio responsive medicines, and adaptable packaging.[35]

 4D printing has a wide range of uses in pharmacy. Through more effective and customized treatment options, these technologies will continue to progress their research and enhance patient results. A significant step toward creating the pharmacy of the future, where care is not only individualized but also dynamically sensitive to each patient's demands and physiological situations, is the combination of smart materials with 4D printing.[36,37]

New prospects in the pharmaceutical industry, particularly in drug delivery systems, have been made possible by recent advancements in 4D printing technology. With an emphasis on practical examples and proof-of-concept prototypes, this section presents a number of case studies and recent advancements that demonstrate the revolutionary potential of 4D printing in the pharmacy industry.[38]

4.Case Studies and Current Advances

Systems for Drug Delivery That Respond

Responsive drug delivery systems are one of the most promising research aspects of 4D printing. Researchers created medicine delivery capsules made from a hydrogel, which interact with different pH values present in the gastrointestinal tract; content’s release can be tailored to predetermined pH thresholds. Increased therapeutic benefit is achieved through improved dosage-regimen efficiency, and side effects are reduced by non-release of drugs at undesired locations.[39,40]

The work of Zu et al. is a good example, they developed a bioinspired hydrogel capsule for intelligent management of drug delivery67. Feasible precise release profile could be obtained because pH and temperature response parts in the capsule allows treatment customization.[41]

2. Implantable Devices for Dynamic Drug Delivery

The goal of developing controllable polymers embedded in implantable devices is also very noteworthy innovation for 4D printing. For instance, vascular stents have been developed by scientists which are made from thermoresponsive materials that will change their shape and release medication at a certain body temperature. There’s no need for invasive surgeries. These devices can be implanted during less invasive procedures and will remodel to the patient’s anatomy in due time. International Journal of Pharmaceutics published a report on this, whereby a vascular stent was designed using memory shape polymer advanced materials that would regain their shape when a certain temperature is maintained thus allowing prolonged control of drug release. To aid in the modification of patients’ quality of life and mitigates chronic medical condition, such a flexibility is vital.[43-45]

3. Systems for Bio-responsive Drug Delivery

Due to the intelligent materials that are used to disclose a certain biological trigger, bio- responsive systems are classed as advanced bio-responsive systems for the targeted delivery of drugs. For example, a drug was targeted in a tumour tissue by employing an enzymatically biodegradable polymer that dissolves in the area populated by a specific enzyme that is found to predominate in tumours. This approach helps in minimizing systemic exposures but increases effectiveness of the drug. [46]

In another satisfying creative work, the researchers designed a hyaluronic acid-based hydrogel that could respond to low oxygenation and acidic pH in tumor environments by releasing loaded anti-cancer drugs. This’s work also reveals tremendous implications of 4D printing technology in oncological applications by enabling delivery of drugs depending upon the local environment of the tumour site.[47]

4. Adaptive Packaging Solutions

Apart from the concept of administering drugs directly in the body, 4D printing technology is also harnessed in the manufacture of flexible structures of packaging for pharmaceutical products. Such a packaging system is designed to recover from deformation due to temperature or humidity affecting the integrity of the engraving of the sensitive medication. For instance, such moisture-sensitive pharmaceuticals are safeguarded by materials that respond to humidity during storage and eliminate sensitive elements from the package when necessary. [48-50]

This is essential with respect to the safety of the patients and stability of the products because the pharmaceutical products can be maintained throughout the entire shelf life under the proper storage conditions.[51]

5.Proof-of-Concept Prototype

As a result of ongoing investigations into the applications of 4D printing in pharmacies, multiple conceptual models have been developed.[52]

Researchers developed a hydrogel bilayer micro-robot which can change its morphology in response to specific pH levels providing targeted drug delivery. This technology has prospects in providing target cancer therapy as it helps in delivering the drugs to the site needed by magnetic orientation. [53-55]

Smarter Implants: Researchers have managed to design better dental implants with the 4d printing technology such that as the patient’s oral structure changes over time, so does the implant. This could result in improved comfort and functionality of the implants with no further procedures required. [56,57]

Dynamic Rehabilitation Devices: The primary feature of such rehabilitation devices were 4d printed dynamic braces or splints that alter their level of stiffness and support based on the movements and conditions of the patients.[58]

Innovation in pharmaceutical applications for enhancing medication delivery systems and patient’s conditions are enabled by emerging 4D printing technologies. Implantable devices, adaptive packaging, and responsive drug-release capsules are a few examples of what can be achieved when high-performance materials are merged with new state-of-the-art fabrication technologies. 4D printing is expected to impact more directly on the lives of patients in the near future within the scope of personalized medicine by providing patient-specific therapeutic solutions that meet accurately the specific needs of each single patient, achieving efficient and economic treatments.[59-62]

6.Challenges and Limitations

Personalized medicine and drug delivery systems can be imagined to be revolutionized by the ability of 4D printing in pharmacies. However, there are many obstacles and restrictions that must be addressed before this technology can be realized in practice. The issues include a poor biocompatibility between remaining bulk materials and tissues with high cell density; lack of compatibility between available 4D printed materials and drugs; high cost for mass production; lack of measurement standards to validate the quality or functionality of the final printed products; regulation requirements prior to patient administration; fabrication process-induced defects generating over time leading device failure.[63-65]

1. Smart materials  are biocompatible

Ensuring the smart materials used are suitable and biocompatible is one of the main challenges facing 4D printing for pharmaceutical applications. The two materials used in 4D printing, shape memory polymer (SMP) and hydrogel, need to be bio-friendly within the human body as well as withstanding each other during the printing process. Biocompatibility is a must since if there is any negative response then it may lead to inflammation or rejection of either an implant or a drug delivery system. For this reason, researchers need to perform many tests in order to guarantee that these materials won’t create such reactions when they come into contact with biological systems. This also means that choosing the right material becomes much harder due to the fact that its degradation products have also got to be bio-friendly and nontoxic.[66,67]

2. Cost and Scalability in Large-Scale Manufacturing

Another key limitation is the high cost of 4D printing technology and its inability to support mass production. The disruption to classical manufacturing caused by the on demand manufacturing enabled by 3D printing is already serious, but these challenges are made worse in 4D printing. The synthesis techniques for producing smart materials in particular are often very expensive, complicated and time-consuming. Ensuring quality control when manufacturing at scale is also challenging. Current production processes are not adapted to meeting the specific needs of 4D printed objects, thereby limiting its applicability across a broad spectrum of applications within the pharmaceutical industry.[68-70]

3. Difficulties with Standardisation and Regulatory Barriers

However, in the pharmacy sector, 4D printing also presents standardisation challenges and regulation challenges. Such a phenomenon is relatively new, and thus the regulators’ means towards the application of this technology in the pharmaceutical sector are still emerging. It could lead one to wonder how the approval of new medicine delivery systems or medical devices manufactured using 4D printing techniques would be handled. To ensure quality and safety of the products, the materials and the processes must be standardised. In the absence of the different set of guidelines and regulations, it appears that manufacturers could find difficulties in marketing their inventions.[71,72]

4. The Stability of Smart Materials Used in Pharmacy in the Future

Last, it is important to emphasize that smart materials used in the pharmacies do not lose their effectiveness or change in structure with time. There exist many intelligent materials that are designed to undergo deformation or change with the application of certain conditions, but little is known about the behaviour patterns of such materials over time. Over time, biological interactions and environmental conditions such as temperature and humidity will limit the stability and function of these materials. It is particularly crucial for drug delivery applications since it determines the initial and final performance of smart materials within the designated duration. As such, it is therefore clear that more emphasis should be placed on time in order to develop trustworthy products.[73,74]

7.Prospects for the Future

Pharmacy 4D printing is expected to increase tremendously thanks to advancements made in material science, attachment of computers and systems into the processes, as well as on demand automated manufacturing. It is envisaged that such advancements will enhance the prediction models of material response, accelerate the rate at which pharmaceuticals are produced and enhance the performance of smart materials in terms of reactivity and strength.[75-77]

1. Material Science Innovations

The developments in material science are still an important factor in regards to enhancing the features that the smart materials in 4D printing are capable of offering. To enhance the durability and reactivity, novel kinds of stimuli responsive materials would be fabricated. For example, the blends of various inorganic nanoparticles and polyester based polymers would combine to enhance the stability and mechanical properties in physiological environments. A fusion of developing materials that can withstand biological environments but are responsive to external stimuli of pH, temperature, light has been the objective here. [78-80]Furthermore, there is a rise in concern regarding the research of such bio materials that are not only biodegradable but also biocompatible. The problem of toxicity and chronic implantation may be circumvented by designing smart materials that can be broken down within the body after the therapeutic effect is gained. Bioactive materials with more complex polymers may be combined.[68]

Combining bioactive substances with sophisticated polymers may potentially enable tailored drug delivery systems that release drugs in a regulated way in response to

particular biological stimuli.[80-83]
 

2. Predictive Modelling Integration with AI

There is a potential improvement in the predictive modelling of the behaviour of smart materials when AI is integrated with the development and application of 4D printing Technology. Through the use of AI algorithms, scientists will be able to view experimental data focused on the evolution of materials in response to stimuli over time. This may allow for the emulations of numerous situations before the construction of physical prototypes, which may greatly shorten the design cycle for novel drug delivery and medical devices. [84,85]Variations in polymer and additive combinations can be applied to machine learning techniques to create desirable properties in smart materials. AI can help ensure that the end products meet exceptionally high quality standards throughout the printing process for real-time supervision and control. Thanks to the capacity of 4D printing to predict the behaviour of materials, these drug products will be able to be more reliable and highly effective. [86-90]

3. Automated Pharmaceutical Manufacturing: Capability of Providing Medicines on Demand.

Another promising prospect for future studies is the automated mass production of medicines on demand, where 4D printing may be utilized. New possibilities to gain significant time and resources would allow to introduce a large number of new drugs and further customize pharmaceuticals in accordance to the needs of specific patients. Automated systems may allow pharmacies to produce customized dosage forms or medicine delivery devices at the point of care and thereby reduce reliance on passive supply chains and manufacturing systems.[91-95].On-demand manufacture, such as this one, would not only improve patient compliance but also reduce waste linked with inventory stock and overproduction as medicines are made according to the requirement of the patient. [96-99]Moreover, patient-negative responses may be simulated and additional conveniently health-related parameters can be used to adjust therapy in real time due to know-how about 4D printing and IoT technologies. In conclusion, there are many areas of improvement in 4D printing for pharmacies which could change the future of personalized medicines as well as drug delivery systems.[100-105]

 CONCLUSION

Pharmacy has undergone a major evolution employing smart materials with 4D printing technology which has enabled the creation of dynamic, patient-specific, and responsive solutions which have transformed this scientific discipline. Brought about by pharmaceuticals designed around controlling drug delivery through timed release mechanisms, this enables a major shift in personalised medicine, which is what 4D printing is all about. 4D printing as well as smart materials such as hydrogels and shape memory polymers can offer solutions to persistent challenges in drug delivery, implant design, and pharmaceutical logistics.
The development of this technology should address the issues of scalability, regulation, and biocompatibility. For innovation to advance and accelerate clinical adoption, cooperation between material scientists, pharmaceutical researchers, biomedical engineers, and regulatory agencies is necessary. Future studies should concentrate on improving the durability and responsiveness of smart materials, optimising material properties, and incorporating artificial intelligence for 4D-printed system predictive modelling. The pharmaceutical business can fully utilise smart materials in 4D printing and usher in a new era of adaptable healthcare solutions by encouraging a cooperative and forward-thinking approach.

REFERENCES

1. 3D and 4D Printing: A Review on Current Developments and Pharmaceuticals Applications Nikita Naidu, Sagar Trivedi, Kamlesh Wadher and Milind Umekar 2021 Vol: 13 Issue: 3
2. Javaid M, Haleem A. 4D printing applications in medical field: a brief review. Clinical Epidemiology and Global Health. 2019 Sep 1;7(3):317-21.
3. Grinberg D, Siddique S, Le MQ, Liang R, Capsal JF, Cottinet PJ. 4D Printing based piezoelectric composite for medical applications. Journal of Polymer Science Part B: Polymer Physics. 2019 Jan 15;57(2):109-15.
4. Kumar S, Kumar R. Overview of 3D and 4D Printing Techniques and their Emerging Applications in Medical Sectors. Current Materials Science: Formerly: Recent Patents on Materials Science. 2023 Jul 1;16(2):143-70.
5. Kumari G, Abhishek K, Singh S, Hussain A, Altamimi MA, Madhyastha H, Webster TJ, Dev A. A voyage from 3D to 4D printing in nanomedicine and healthcare: Part II. Nanomedicine. 2022 Feb;17(4):255-70.
6. Sajjad R, Chauhdary ST, Anwar MT, Zahid A, Khosa AA, Imran M, Sajjad MH. A review of 4D printing–technologies, shape shifting, smart polymer based materials, and biomedical applications. Advanced Industrial and Engineering Polymer Research. 2024 Jan 1;7(1):20-36.
7. Joshi S, Rawat K, Karunakaran C, Rajamohan V, Mathew AT, Koziol K, Thakur VK, Balan AS. 4D printing of materials for the future: Opportunities and challenges. Applied Materials Today. 2020 Mar 1;18:100490.
8. Mitchell A, Lafont U, Ho?y?ska M, Semprimoschnig CJ. Additive manufacturing—A review of 4D printing and future applications. Additive Manufacturing. 2018 Dec 1;24:606-26.
9. Ramezani M, Mohd Ripin Z. 4D printing in biomedical engineering: Advancements, challenges, and future directions. Journal of functional biomaterials. 2023 Jun 29;14(7):347.
10. Ranjan N, Kumar V, Ozdemir OB. 3D to 4D printing: Perspective and development. In4D Printing of Composites 2024 Jan 1 (pp. 1-21). Woodhead Publishing.
11. Sharma P, Jain V. An overview of current advances and pharmaceutical uses of 3D and 4D printing. Explor Med. 2023;4:560-75.
12. Appuhamillage GA, Ambagaspitiya SS, Dassanayake RS, Wijenayake A. 3D and 4D printing of biomedical materials: current trends, challenges, and future outlook. Exploration of Medicine. 2024 Feb 6;5(1):17-47.
13. Khalid MY, Arif ZU, Ahmed W. 4D printing: technological and manufacturing renaissance. Macromolecular Materials and Engineering. 2022 Aug;307(8):2200003.
14. Ameta KL, Solanki VS, Singh V, Devi AP, Chundawat RS, Haque S. Critical appraisal and systematic review of 3D & 4D printing in sustainable and environment-friendly smart manufacturing technologies. Sustainable Materials and Technologies. 2022 Dec 1;34:e00481.
15. Javaid M, Haleem A, Singh RP, Rab S, Suman R, Kumar L. Significance of 4D printing for dentistry: Materials, process, and potentials. Journal of Oral Biology and Craniofacial Research. 2022 May 1;12(3):388-95.
16. Lui YS, Sow WT, Tan LP, Wu Y, Lai Y, Li H. 4D printing and stimuli-responsive materials in biomedical aspects. Acta biomaterialia. 2019 Jul 1;92:19-36.
17. Raina A, Haq MI, Javaid M, Rab S, Haleem A. 4D printing for automotive industry applications. Journal of The Institution of Engineers (India): Series D. 2021 Dec:1-9.
18. Teng X, Zhang M, Mujumdar AS. 4D printing: Recent advances and proposals in the food sector. Trends in Food Science & Technology. 2021 Apr 1;110:349-63.
19. Zhang Z, Demir KG, Gu GX. Developments in 4D-printing: a review on current smart materials, technologies, and applications. International Journal of Smart and Nano Materials. 2019 Jul 3;10(3):205-24.
20. Ryan KR, Down MP, Banks CE. Future of additive manufacturing: Overview of 4D and 3D printed smart and advanced materials and their applications. Chemical Engineering Journal. 2021 Jan 1;403:126162.
21. Pugliese R, Regondi S. Artificial intelligence-empowered 3D and 4D printing technologies toward smarter biomedical materials and approaches. Polymers. 2022 Jul 8;14(14):2794.
22. Borse K, Shende P. 3D-to-4D Structures: An Exploration in Biomedical Applications. Aaps Pharmscitech. 2023 Aug 3;24(6):163.
23. Aldawood FK. A comprehensive review of 4D printing: state of the arts, opportunities, and challenges. InActuators 2023 Feb 25 (Vol. 12, No. 3, p. 101). MDPI.
24. Noroozi R, Arif ZU, Taghvaei H, Khalid MY, Sahbafar H, Hadi A, Sadeghianmaryan A, Chen X. 3D and 4D bioprinting technologies: a game changer for the biomedical sector?. Annals of Biomedical Engineering. 2023 Aug;51(8):1683-712.
25. Tamay DG, Dursun Usal T, Alagoz AS, Yucel D, Hasirci N, Hasirci V. 3D and 4D printing of polymers for tissue engineering applications. Frontiers in bioengineering and biotechnology. 2019 Jul 9;7:164.
26. Zafar MQ, Zhao H. 4D printing: future insight in additive manufacturing. Metals and Materials International. 2020 May;26:564-85.
27. Mahmood A, Akram T, Shenggui C, Chen H. Revolutionizing manufacturing: A review of 4D printing materials, stimuli, and cutting-edge applications. Composites Part B: Engineering. 2023 Sep 6:110952.
28. Biswas MC, Chakraborty S, Bhattacharjee A, Mohammed Z. 4D printing of shape memory materials for textiles: mechanism, mathematical modeling, and challenges. Advanced Functional Materials. 2021 May;31(19):2100257.
29. Kantaros A, Ganetsos T, Piromalis D. 4D Printing: Technology Overview and Smart Materials Utilized. Kantaros, A., Ganetsos, T. & Piromalis, D.(2023). 4D Printing: Technology Overview and Smart Materials Utilized. Journal of Mechatronics and Robotics. 2023 Feb 21;7(1):1-4.
30. Sharma S, Tyagi R, Mohan S. 14 Additive manufacturing and 4D printing applications for Industry 4.0-enabled digital biomedical and pharmaceutical sectors. 3D Printing Technologies: Digital Manufacturing, Artificial Intelligence, Industry 4.0. 2024 Jan 29:289.
31. Kantaros A, Ganetsos T, Piromalis D. 3D and 4D printing as integrated manufacturing methods of industry 4.0. Kantaros, A., Ganetsos, T. & Piromalis, D.(2023). 3D and 4D Printing as Integrated Manufacturing Methods of Industry. 2023 Feb 8;4:12-22.
32. Mehta P, Sahlot P. Application of phase change materials in 4D printing: A review. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2021 Jan 1;47:4746-52.
33. McLellan K, Sun YC, Naguib HE. A review of 4D printing: Materials, structures, and designs towards the printing of biomedical wearable devices. Bioprinting. 2022 Aug 1;27:e00217.
34. Sheikh A, Abourehab MA, Kesharwani P. The clinical significance of 4D printing. Drug Discovery Today. 2023 Jan 1;28(1):103391.
35. Khorsandi D, Fahimipour A, Abasian P, Saber SS, Seyedi M, Ghanavati S, Ahmad A, De Stephanis AA, Taghavinezhaddilami F, Leonova A, Mohammadinejad R. 3D and 4D printing in dentistry and maxillofacial surgery: Printing techniques, materials, and applications. Acta biomaterialia. 2021 Mar 1;122:26-49.
36. Kumar P, Suryavanshi P, Dwivedy SK, Banerjee S. Stimuli-responsive materials for 4D Printing: Mechanical, Manufacturing, and Biomedical Applications. Journal of Molecular Liquids. 2024 Jul 16:125553.
37. Choi J, Kwon OC, Jo W, Lee HJ, Moon MW. 4D printing technology: a review. 3D Printing and Additive Manufacturing. 2015 Dec 1;2(4):159-67.
38. Tran TS, Balu R, Mettu S, Roy Choudhury N, Dutta NK. 4D printing of hydrogels: innovation in material design and emerging smart systems for drug delivery. Pharmaceuticals. 2022 Oct 19;15(10):1282.
39. Deshmukh K, Houkan MT, AlMaadeed MA, Sadasivuni KK. Introduction to 3D and 4D printing technology: State of the art and recent trends. 3D and 4D printing of polymer nanocomposite materials. 2020 Jan 1:1-24.
40. Egon A, Bell C, Shad R. 4D Printing: Advancements and Applications: Research in the emerging field of 4D printing.
41. Gobena ST, Woldeyohannes AD. Comparative review on the application of smart material in additive manufacturing: 3D and 4D printing. Discover Applied Sciences. 2024 Jun 26;6(7):353.
42. Leist SK, Zhou J. Current status of 4D printing technology and the potential of light-reactive smart materials as 4D printable materials. Virtual and Physical Prototyping. 2016 Oct 1;11(4):249-62.
43. Chalissery D, Schönfeld D, Walter M, Shklyar I, Andrae H, Schwörer C, Amann T, Weisheit L, Pretsch T. Highly shrinkable objects as obtained from 4D printing. Macromolecular Materials and Engineering. 2022 Jan;307(1):2100619.
44. Nizam M, Purohit R, Taufik M. Materials for 3D printing in healthcare sector: A review. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine. 2024 Oct;238(10):939-63.
45. Cheng Y, Fu Y, Ma L, Yap PL, Losic D, Wang H, Zhang Y. Rheology of edible food inks from 2D/3D/4D printing, and its role in future 5D/6D printing. Food Hydrocolloids. 2022 Nov 1;132:107855.
46. Firth J, Gaisford S, Basit AW. A new dimension: 4D printing opportunities in pharmaceutics. 3D printing of pharmaceuticals. 2018:153-62.
47. Kumari G, Abhishek K, Singh S, Hussain A, Altamimi MA, Madhyastha H, Webster TJ, Dev A. A voyage from 3D to 4D printing in nanomedicine and healthcare: Part I. Nanomedicine. 2022 Feb;17(4):237-53.
48. Taylor S, Mueller E, Jones LR, Makela AV, Ashammakhi N. Translational Aspects of 3D and 4D Printing and Bioprinting. Advanced Healthcare Materials. 2024 Oct;13(27):2400463.
49. Haleem A, Javaid M, Vaishya R. 5D printing and its expected applications in Orthopaedics. Journal of clinical orthopaedics and trauma. 2018 Nov 30;10(4):809.
50. Wang H, Guo J. Recent advances in 4D printing hydrogel for biological interfaces. International Journal of Material Forming. 2023 Sep;16(5):55.
51. Maraveas C, Bayer IS, Bartzanas T. 4D printing: Perspectives for the production of sustainable plastics for agriculture. Biotechnology Advances. 2022 Jan 1;54:107785.
52. Maidin S, Wee KJ, Sharum MA, Rajendran TK, Ali LM, Ismail S. A review on 4D additive manufacturing-the applications, smart materials & effect of various stimuli on 4d printed objects. Jurnal teknologi. 2023 Aug 21;85(5):63-71.
53. Sadraei A, Naghib SM. 4D printing of physical stimuli-responsive hydrogels for localized drug delivery and tissue engineering. Polymer Reviews. 2024 Nov 9:1-65.
54. Agarwal K, Srinivasan V, Lather V, Pandita D, Vasanthan KS. Insights of 3D bioprinting and focusing the paradigm shift towards 4D printing for biomedical applications. Journal of Materials Research. 2023 Jan 14;38(1):112-41.
55. Khan A, Iqbal MJ, Amin S, Bilal H, Noor A, Mir B, Kaur MD. 4D printing: the dawn of “smart” drug delivery systems and biomedical applications. Journal of Drug Delivery and Therapeutics. 2021 Oct 15;11(5-S):131-7.
56. Subeshan B, Baddam Y, Asmatulu E. Current progress of 4D-printing technology. Progress in Additive Manufacturing. 2021 Aug;6:495-516.
57. Singh B, Chohan JS, Kumar R. Social and economic aspects of 4D printing. In4D Printing of Composites 2024 Jan 1 (pp. 159-171). Woodhead Publishing.
58. Trenfield SJ, Awad A, Madla CM, Hatton GB, Firth J, Goyanes A, Gaisford S, Basit AW. Shaping the future: recent advances of 3D printing in drug delivery and healthcare. Expert opinion on drug delivery. 2019 Oct 3;16(10):1081-94.
59. Baig A, Barse R, Paryekar A, Jagtap V. Evolution of Pharmaceuticals using 3D and 4D Printing. Intelligent Pharmacy. 2024 May 25.
60. Khalid MY, Arif ZU, Noroozi R, Hossain M, Ramakrishna S, Umer R. 3D/4D printing of cellulose nanocrystals-based biomaterials: Additives for sustainable applications. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules. 2023 Aug 11:126287.
61. Wan X, Luo L, Liu Y, Leng J. Direct ink writing based 4D printing of materials and their applications. Advanced Science. 2020 Aug;7(16):2001000.
62. Mathur V, Agarwal P, Srinivasan V, Panwar A, Vasanthan KS. Facet of 4D printing in biomedicine. Journal of Materials Research. 2023 Jan 14;38(1):2-18.
63. Ramesh S, Kiran reddy S, Usha C, Naulakha NK, Adithyakumar CR, Lohith Kumar Reddy M. Advancements in the research of 4D printing-a review. InIOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering 2018 Jun 1 (Vol. 376, p. 012123). IOP Publishing.
64. Shinde S, Mane R, Vardikar A, Dhumal A, Rajput A. 4D printing: From emergence to innovation over 3D printing. European Polymer Journal. 2023 Aug 9:112356.
65. Chinnakorn A, Nuansing W, Kouzani AZ, Bodaghi M, Zolfagharian A. 4D Printing: The Next Dimension of Healthcare in Cancer Research. InAdditive Manufacturing in Pharmaceuticals 2023 Sep 14 (pp. 237-269). Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
66. Sood K, Sood SK. Mapping the future: a scientometric review of 3D/4D printing research trends. Progress in Additive Manufacturing. 2024 Nov 1:1-5.
67. Kokane SB, Arora VK, Thangalakshmi S. Potential of Bioactive Ingredients for Healthy 4D Food Printing: Applications and Challenges. Food Reviews International. 2024 Nov 11;40(10):3792-815.
68. Lalegani Dezaki M, Zolfagharian A, Demoly F, Bodaghi M. Human–Material Interaction Enabled by Fused Filament Fabrication 4D Printing. Advanced Engineering Materials. 2024 Apr;26(7):2301917.
69. Lalegani Dezaki M, Zolfagharian A, Demoly F, Bodaghi M. Human–Material Interaction Enabled by Fused Filament Fabrication 4D Printing. Advanced Engineering Materials. 2024 Apr;26(7):2301917.
70. Perambudhuru Y, Goyal L, Dewan M, Mahajan A, Chaudhari PK. Application of 4D printing in dentistry: A narrative review. Journal of Advanced Periodontology & Implant Dentistry. 2024 Mar 16;16(1):55.
71. Malashin I, Masich I, Tynchenko V, Gantimurov A, Nelyub V, Borodulin A, Martysyuk D, Galinovsky A. Machine Learning in 3D and 4D Printing of Polymer Composites: A Review. Polymers. 2024 Nov 8;16(22):3125.
72. Abdullah T, Okay O. 4D printing of body temperature-responsive hydrogels based on poly (acrylic acid) with shape-memory and self-healing abilities. ACS Applied Bio Materials. 2023 Jan 26;6(2):703-11.
73. Firoozi AA, Firoozi AA. A systematic review of the role of 4D printing in sustainable civil engineering solutions. Heliyon. 2023 Oct 16.
74. Mahmood A, Perveen F, Chen S, Akram T, Irfan A. Polymer Composites in 3D/4D Printing: Materials, Advances, and Prospects. Molecules. 2024 Jan 9;29(2):319.
75. Malekmohammadi S, Sedghi Aminabad N, Sabzi A, Zarebkohan A, Razavi M, Vosough M, Bodaghi M, Maleki H. Smart and biomimetic 3D and 4D printed composite hydrogels: opportunities for different biomedical applications. Biomedicines. 2021 Oct 26;9(11):1537.
76. Kim J, Gouripriya DA, Saha P. 4D?Printed, Smart, Multiresponsive Structures and Their Applications. 3D Bioprinting from Lab to Industry. 2024 Aug 2:231-50.
77. Dezaki ML, Zolfagharian A, Demoly F, Bodaghi M. Human?Material Interaction Enabled by FFF 4D Printing. Advanced Engineering Materials. 2024.
78. Di Salvo S. Biomimetics and 4D Printing: A Synergy for the Development of Innovative Materials. InBiomimetics, Biodesign and Bionics: Technological Advances Toward Sustainable Development 2024 May 14 (pp. 173-200). Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland.
79. Lamprou D, editor. 3D & 4D Printing Methods for Pharmaceutical Manufacturing and Personalised Drug Delivery: Opportunities and Challenges.
80. Sondagar HD, Kumar S, Sharma VS. A state-of-the-art review of 4D printing techniques, stimuli activated materials and future perspectives. Materials Today: Proceedings. 2024 Jan 19.
81. Solanki A, Ranganath MS, Singholi AK. Review on advancements in 3D/4D printing for enhancing efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and quality. International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM). 2024 Aug 3:1-7.
82. Escalante?Aburto A, Trujillo?de Santiago G, Álvarez MM, Chuck?Hernández C. Advances and prospective applications of 3D food printing for health improvement and personalized nutrition. Comprehensive reviews in food science and food safety. 2021 Nov;20(6):5722-41.
83. Pingale P, Dawre S, Dhapte-Pawar V, Dhas N, Rajput A. Advances in 4D printing: From stimulation to simulation. Drug Delivery and Translational Research. 2023 Jan;13(1):164-88.
84. Farid MI, Wu W, Guiwei L, Yu Z. Research on imminent enlargements of smart materials and structures towards novel 4D printing (4DP: SMs-SSs). The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. 2023 Jun;126(7):2803-23.
85. Zhang L, Huang X, Cole T, Lu H, Hang J, Li W, Tang SY, Boyer C, Davis TP, Qiao R. 3D-printed liquid metal polymer composites as NIR-responsive 4D printing soft robot. Nature Communications. 2023 Nov 28;14(1):7815.
86. Ahmed K, Shiblee MN. 4D printing of soft sensors in robotics. InSmart Materials in Addititve Manufacturing, Volume 3 2024 Jan 1 (pp. 99-124). Elsevier.
87. Agarwal P, Mathur V, Kasturi M, Srinivasan V, Seetharam RN, S Vasanthan K. A Futuristic Development in 3D Printing Technique Using Nanomaterials with a Step Toward 4D Printing. ACS omega. 2024 Aug 26;9(36):37445-58.
88. Xin X, Liu L, Liu Y, Leng J. 4D printing auxetic metamaterials with tunable, programmable, and reconfigurable mechanical properties. Advanced Functional Materials. 2020 Oct;30(43):2004226.
89. Sardar T, Mishra S, Pandey S, Mishra A, khan A, Parmar B, Sanghai S, Mudgal M. Recent Advancement in 3D and 4D Printing. InInternational Conference on Mechanical Engineering 2023 Sep 1 (pp. 135-141). Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
90. Khoo ZX, Teoh JE, Liu Y, Chua CK, Yang S, An J, Leong KF, Yeong WY. 3D printing of smart materials: A review on recent progresses in 4D printing. Virtual and Physical Prototyping. 2015 Jul 3;10(3):103-22.
91. Basak S. Is 4D Printing at the Forefront of Transformations in Tissue Engineering and Beyond?. Biomedical Materials & Devices. 2024 Sep;2(2):587-600.
92. Le Duigou A, Correa D, Ueda M, Matsuzaki R, Castro M. A review of 3D and 4D printing of natural fibre biocomposites. Materials & Design. 2020 Sep 1;194:108911.
93. Hassib MA, Islam MR, Karim MR, Hasan MS, Hossain KR. RESEARCH PROGRESS OF 4D PRINTING TECHNOLOGY. Kufa Journal of Engineering. 2024 Aug 2;15(3):107-33.
94. Rastogi P, Kandasubramanian B. Breakthrough in the printing tactics for stimuli-responsive materials: 4D printing. Chemical Engineering Journal. 2019 Jun 15;366:264-304.
95. Ahmed K, Shiblee MN, Khosla A, Nagahara L, Thundat T, Furukawa H. Recent progresses in 4D printing of gel materials. Journal of The Electrochemical Society. 2020 Feb 6;167(3):037563.
96. Joharji L, Mishra RB, Alam F, Tytov S, Al-Modaf F, El-Atab N. 4D printing: A detailed review of materials, techniques, and applications. Microelectronic Engineering. 2022 Sep 15;265:111874.
97. Dasankoppa FS, Sidhaye I, Yashaswini R, Karadagi AV, Pujar T, Sholapur HN, Harish KH, Nagathan VV. A Review on 4D Printing Technology for Fabrication of Intelligent, Programmable and Functional Structure. TWIST. 2024 May 27;19(2):421-31.
98. Thakur V, Singh R, Kumar R, Sharma S, Singh S, Li C, Zhang Y, Eldin SM, Alqarni SA. Mechanically sustainable and primary recycled thermo-responsive ABS–PLA polymer composites for 4D printing applications: Fabrication and studies. Reviews on Advanced Materials Science. 2024 Jul 24;63(1):20230149.
99. Vasishta BV, Preetham TH, Akhil UV, Radhika N. An overview of the evolution of additive manufacturing from 3d to 5d printing in biomedical applications. Progress in Additive Manufacturing. 2024 Oct 28:1-7.
100. Mallakpour S, Tabesh F, Hussain CM. Entering a new era in pharmaceutics through 3D/4D printing technologies. InMedical Additive Manufacturing 2024 Jan 1 (pp. 267-280). Elsevier.
101. Al-Taweel AF. The Role of 4D Printing Materials, Process and Potentials for Dentistry. International journal of health sciences.;6(S4):7356-64.
102. Thanigachalam M, Chinnappan BA, Raghavan P. Applications and Future Aspects of 4D Printed Biopolymeric Scaffold Materials in Tissue Engineering: A Systematic Literature Review. Applied Science and Engineering Progress. 2023 Aug 23;16(3):6704-.
103. Sharma P, Jain V. An overview of current advances and pharmaceutical uses of 3D and 4D printing. Explor Med. 2023;4:560-75.
104. Gazzaniga A, Foppoli A, Cerea M, Palugan L, Cirilli M, Moutaharrik S, Melocchi A, Maroni A. Towards 4D printing in pharmaceutics. International Journal of Pharmaceutics: X. 2023 Dec 1;5:100171.
105. Mandal A, Chatterjee K. 4D printing for biomedical applications. Journal of Materials Chemistry B. 2024;12(12):2985-3005.

.