Department of Pharmacy, Shree Dev Bhoomi Institute of Education Science and Technology, (Affiliated from VMSB Uttarakhand Technical University) Dehradun, Uttarakhand-248011.
Mirabegron & silodosin, is used often in combination as bilayer tablets, are primarily used to treat the symptoms of overactive bladder (OAB) & benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH). Mirabegron drug helps to relax bladder muscles by increasing urine storage capacity and reduction in urine urgency. The drug Silodosin helps to relax the muscles in the prostate and bladder neck by improving urinary flow and reducing BPH-related symptoms. The aim of the research study is to process validation (PV) of the formulation development of bilayer tablet of Mirabegron & silodosin drug. Process validation batches were manufactured for the demonstration of the process performance for reproducibility and consistency within its range of operation as per process design. Mirabegron to be manufactured in extended-release form for prolonged action and silodosin in immediate release form. Based on the results of the validation process, the observed results indicate that the process design for the manufacturing of the product, mirabegron and silodosin tablet 25mg & 8 mg is found to be robust enough for manufacturing of a quality drug product. These validated products give the specified quality attribute results & meet all the predetermined specification criteria. The PV study highlights the potential of a Mirabegron ER & Silodosin bilayer tablet approach, combining immediate release & Extended-release formulation, for creating an extended-release dosage form mirabegron & immediate release dosage form of silodosin.
Bilayer tablets continue to represent a new era in which controlled delivery design can be effectively advanced laterally through a variety of methods to provide an approach to an effective drug transport system (Han et al., 2022). Bi-layer tablets appear to be designed for the simultaneous release of two drugs, two discordant constituents, and then similarly for sustained release tablets, where the maintenance dose is the second layer and the immediate release is the first layer. Bilayer tablets continue to be an improved, advantageous way to overcome the shortcomings of single-layered tablets (Maddiboyina et al., 2020). The concept of validation has undergone constant development since it was originally introduced in the US in 1978.The idea of validation has grown over time to include a variety of tasks, from computerized systems for clinical trials to analytical techniques used for quality control of pharmacological ingredients and items. Because each process is so different, there is one-size-fits all method for validation and regulatory agencies like the FDA and EC have created broad optional standards (Ishitsubo et al., 2024). Nevertheless, validation is one component of quality assurance related to a specific process. The term validation simply implies "action of proving effectiveness" or "assessment of validity." Validation, as defined by the European Community for pharmaceutical products, is the "action of proving" that any procedure, process, requirement, material, activity, or system genuinely produces the desired results in line with GMP principles. A documented procedure that offers a high level of assurance that a particular process will reliably yield a product that satisfies its predefined specifications and quality attributes is known as process validation (Swetanshu et al., 2020). Mirabegron (Mrb), a β3-adrenoceptor agonist, was a new class of pharmaceutical treatment for OAB. The mechanism of action differences suggest that adding a β3-adrenoceptor agonist to an antimuscarinic agent could enhance efficacy in the treatment of OAB (Lee et al., 2019). The european urology association guideline recommends α-1-blokers for distal ureteric stones. Tamsulosin and silodosin are the most commonly used alpha1-blokers in medical expulsive therapy. Silodosin has a 38-fold higher selectivity for α-1A than tamsulosin. In a study by Gupta et al, tamsulosin and silodosin had expulsion rates of 58% and 82%, respectively. Silodosin was also associated with a shorter expulsion time compared to tamsulosin. In the opposite way of thinking, ureter relaxation may be helpful for easy F-URS procedure, and this can easily be achieved by administering silodosin preoperatively (Diab et al., 2024).
Mirabegron was purchased from MSN Laboratories Pvt. Ltd. (Telangana, India). Silodosin purchased from PRUDENCE PHARMA CHEM, Microcrystalline cellulose (Ankit pharma), lactose monohydrate (MODERN DAIRIES LIMITED), sodium starch glycolate (SUDEEP PHARMA PVT. LTD.), povidone (SUDEEP PHARMA PVT. LTD.), HPMC K4 M (coloron India), polyethylene glycol 6000 (Vasudha chemicals, Mumbai, India), magnesium stearate (SKANT India), and colloidal silicon dioxide were purchased from (CABOT SANMAR LIMITED). Polyethylene oxide (Dupont India). and Opadry® coating agent (Opadry red 85G55308) were purchased from Coloron India.
The formulations are designed for bilayer tablets combining IR (immediate release) and ER (Extended release) components in different ratios. Each drug layer has its separate granulation procedure. For the preparation of Immediate Release (IR) granules, Silodosin, microcrystalline cellulose, lactose monohydrate, and SSG (sodium starch glycolate) were mixed with an inactive binding solution, which is povidone-90 dissolved in purified water, using a high-speed mechanical stirrer. After mixing solutions in dry powder, the wet granules were dried using an FBD. Dried granules were further sized using the 1.0 mm mesh and lubricated with magnesium stearate and Aerosil/colloidal silicon dioxide. For the preparation of SR granules, mirabegron, lactose, starch and HPMC K4 passed through the sieve and further binding done by using PVPK-90. The dry powder was mixed in RMG, and further binding has been done by the binding agent and dried by using FBD 120 kg. Dried granules sized by 1.0 mm mesh and mixed using Double cone Blender 185 ltr capacity. After mixing, the granules were lubricated with magnesium stearate (Jadiya et al., 2024). The both layer granules were further compressed to form the bilayer tablets consisting of Immediate Release and Sustained release layers using an Cadpress IV compression machine using the round shape plain punches. The compaction pressure was set at 10 kN, to achieve the required hardness of tablets during the process of compression. The batch size was 2.0 lac tablets. After forming the bilayer tablets, the tablets were further coated with Opadry coating material using a solace auto coater 37” capacity. The detailed formulations are shown in table 1 and manufacturing scheme is shown as figure 2.
Table 1. Composition of formulations for bilayer tablet Mirabegron ER and Silodosin.
Sr. No. |
Name of Raw Materials |
Qty./Tablets (mg) |
Qty./Batch (Kg) |
|
Mirabegron Layer |
||||
|
Extended Release |
Mirabegron |
25.38 |
5.076 |
|
Lactose |
124.12 |
24.824 |
|
|
Starch |
33.75 |
6.750 |
|
|
H.P.M.C. (K-4M) |
32 |
6.400 |
|
|
Isopropyl Alcohol |
85 ml |
17.000 Ltr |
|
|
Povidone K-90 |
3 |
0.600 |
|
|
Colloidal Silicon Dioxide |
2.25 |
0.450 |
|
|
Magnesium Stearate |
IP |
0.900 |
|
Silodosin Part |
||||
|
Immediate release |
Silodosin |
8.44 |
1.688 |
|
Lactose |
70.85 |
14.17 |
|
|
Microcrystalline Cellulose |
32.53 |
6.506 |
|
|
Sod starch glycollate |
2.5 |
0.5 |
|
|
Colour Iron Oxide Red |
0.04 |
0.008 |
|
|
Purified Water |
25 |
5 |
|
|
Povidone K-90 |
1.88 |
0.376 |
|
|
Colloidal Silicon Dioxide |
1.25 |
0.25 |
|
|
H.P.M.C. E3 |
3.13 |
0.626 |
|
|
Magnesium Stearate |
1.88 |
0.376 |
|
|
Sod starch glycollate |
2.5 |
0.5 |
|
Coating materials |
||||
|
Opadry red |
8.75 |
1.750 |
|
|
Purified water |
50 |
10 ltr |
Selection of Manufacturing Equipment:
The equipment for the manufacturing of the products has been selected based on the equipment capacity & design. The equipment’s used for the manufacturing of bilayer products has been selected on the basis of manufacturing process design, product batch size, and available and required utility assessment criteria. The list of equipment has been approved based on the manufacturing process of the product Mirabegron Extended Release 25 Mg and Silodosin 8mg Tablet (Bilayer Tablets).
Table 2: Details of Equipment’s Used for the Manufacturing of Batches
Sr. No. |
Equipment Name |
Capacity |
Make |
1 |
Vibro Sifter |
30 Inches |
Tapasya |
2 |
RMG |
120 ltrs. |
Tapasya |
3 |
Multi-mill |
--- |
Avon |
4 |
FBD |
120 kg |
Solace |
5 |
Double Cone Blender |
185 L |
Tapasya |
6 |
Tablet Compression Machine |
45 Stations Bilayer |
Cadmach IV |
7 |
Metal Detector |
NA |
Technofour |
8 |
Vibro DE duster |
NA |
Technofour |
9 |
Auto coater |
37” |
Solace |
10 |
Colloid mill |
10 ltrs |
Tapasya |
11 |
Blister Packing Machine |
40 - 60 cuts/min |
Paam |
12 |
Weighing Balance |
200 g |
Metler Toledo |
13 |
Weighing Balance |
150 Kg |
Metler Toledo |
<a href="https://www.ijpsjournal.com/uploads/createUrl/createUrl-20250604185659-0.png" target="_blank">
<img alt="Flow chart of manufacturing & packaging process.png" height="150" src="https://www.ijpsjournal.com/uploads/createUrl/createUrl-20250604185659-0.png" width="150">
</a>
Figure 1: Flow chart of manufacturing & packaging process
2.4 Process Validation of Mirabegron (ER) and Silodosin Bilayer Tablet:
Various quality and control evaluation parameters were performed for the evaluation of bilayer table formulation. Table 3 described in detail about manufacturing process, process variables and measuring controls.
Table 3: Product Critical Quality Attributes, Risk & control evaluation:
Manufacturing Process |
Process Variables |
Process Measuring Controls |
Initial & Final Sifting |
Granules size |
Sieve Integrity |
Dry Granulation & Wet Granulation |
RMG Occupancy Rpm Impeller Rpm Chopper Amperage Mixing Time |
Content Uniformity |
Semi Drying/ Final Drying |
Inlet Temperature Outlet Temperature Bed Temperature Drying Time |
Drying Time Lod Of Granules |
Lubrication |
Rpm Time |
Assay Bulk Density Particle Size Distribution |
Compression |
Machine Rpm Hopper Level Lubrication Of Machines Compaction Force |
Tablet Appearance Uniformity Of Weight Disintegration Time Hardness Of Tab Thickness Of Tab Friability % % Assay Cu |
Coating |
Spray Rate Coating Pan Rpm Bed Temperature Inlet Temperature Bed Temperature |
Tablet Description % Weight Gain Physical Parameter Assay |
Packing |
Forming & Sealing Temperature Machine Rpm |
Leak Test Knurling Finished Product Quality Attribute |
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
As per the process validation protocol, sampling of products has been carried out in different stages of manufacturing, i.e. granulation, compression, coating & finished stage. The samples are further analyzed as per the specification of evaluation parameters of formulation process of bilayer tablet. The sampling plan of product was mentioned in the approved validation protocol accordingly sampling has been done. The analytical result of the product gives assurance that manufacturing processes are well-validated. Product sampling and analytical results of all the validation batches discussed in the below sections.
Pre-Formulation and Evaluation of Bilayer Tablet:
The analytical results of the formulation development process of bilayer tablet Mirabegron (ER) 25 mg and Silodosin 08 mg were observed in dry mixing stage. Sample was collected from three stages of the mixer i.e. top, middle and bottom. Detailed analytical reports of the samples were shown in table 4 & 5.
Table 4: Analytical Results of Mirabegron (ER) in dry Mixing Stage.
Sampling Point |
Parameters |
Acceptance Criteria |
Observed Results |
||
Trial 1 |
Trial 2 |
Trial 3 |
|||
Top (L1) |
Description |
white coloured granular powder. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Mirabegron EP 25 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
103.2% |
98.8% |
102.3% |
|
Middle (L2) |
Description |
white coloured granular powder. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Mirabegron EP 25 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
100.3% |
102.5% |
101.0% |
|
Bottom (L3) |
Description |
white coloured granular powder. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Mirabegron EP 25 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
103.5% |
101.7% |
98.1% |
|
Composite |
Description |
white coloured granular powder. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Mirabegron EP 25 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
98.9% |
104.7% |
100.6% |
Table 5: Analytical Results of Silodosin in dry Mixing Stage.
Sampling Point |
Parameters |
Acceptance Criteria |
Observed Results |
||
Trial 1 |
Trial 2 |
Trial 3 |
|||
Top (L1) |
Description |
light pink coloured granular powder |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Silodosin JP 08 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
103.2% |
101.8% |
105.5% |
|
Middle (L2) |
Description |
light pink coloured granular powder |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Silodosin JP 08 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
100.3% |
98.6% |
98.8% |
|
Bottom (L3) |
Description |
light pink coloured granular powder |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Silodosin JP 08 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
103.5% |
98.5% |
98.4% |
|
Composite |
Description |
light pink coloured granular powder |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
Silodosin JP 08 mg |
98.0 % to 110.0% of labeled amount |
102.3% |
105.8% |
98.6% |
Formulation and Evaluation of Coated Tablet:
Evaluation process was done for the final coated bilayer tablet of Mirabegron 25 mg and Silodosin 08 mg through various parameters like description, identification, average weight, uniformity of weight and dissolution. The detailed evaluation values of the all parameters are show in table 6.
Table 6: Analytical results of coated tablets.
Parameters |
Acceptance criteria |
Trial 1 |
Trial 2 |
Trial 3 |
|
Description |
Brick red coloured, round, biconvex, bilayered, film coated tablets, plain on both sides. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
|
Identification |
The retention time of the major peak in the chromatogram of test solution should be corresponds to that the standard solution obtained as directed in the assy. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
|
Average Weight |
346.29 to 367.71 mg |
359.39 mg |
357.75 mg |
354.23 mg |
|
Uniformity of weight |
Not more than 2 tablets in 20 deviates from the average weight by more than 5.0%. No tablet deviates from the average weight by more than 10.0%. |
Deviation -3.79 to +1.59% |
Deviation –1.70 to +2.17% |
Deviation -2.37 to +4.04 % |
|
Dissolution |
|||||
1st hour Mirabegron EP |
Not more than 30.0% of Labeled amount |
Minimum |
8.5% |
12.5% |
18.4% |
Maximum |
12.2% |
15.7% |
22.5% |
||
Average |
11.1% |
14.0% |
20.4% |
||
3rd hour Mirabegron EP |
25.0 to 65.0% of labeled amount |
Minimum |
32.3% |
38.1% |
42.1% |
Maximum |
38.9% |
44.4% |
47.0% |
||
Average |
35.1% |
40.4% |
45.9% |
||
10 hour |
Not less than 75.0% of labeled amount |
Minimum |
80.0% |
85.7% |
90.5% |
Maximum |
98.8% |
96.2% |
98.8% |
||
Average |
90.7% |
90.6% |
93.8% |
||
Silodosin JP |
Not less than 70% (Q) of Labeled amount in 45 minutes |
Minimum |
85.3% |
92.3% |
92.2% |
Maximum |
95.3% |
95.6% |
99.1% |
||
Average |
90.3% |
93.9% |
96.3% |
||
Uniformity of Dosage units (By content Uniformity) |
|||||
Mirabegron EP |
Acceptance value should be less than 15 |
9.10 |
11.2 |
5.50 |
|
Silodosin JP |
Acceptance value should be less than 15 |
10.30 |
13.0 |
5.49 |
|
Assay: Each Film coated tablet contains: |
|||||
Mirabegron EP (as extended release form) …….25 mg |
90.0 to 110.0% of labeled amount |
103.0% |
103.4% |
102.5% |
|
Silodosin JP…8 mg |
90.0 to 110.0% of labeled amount |
98.4% |
98.1% |
98.3% |
Formulation and Evaluation of Final Bilayer Tablet:
Formulation of the bilayer tablet of Mirabegron 25 mg and Silodosin 08 mg was done with the help of standard operating procedure. The evaluation of the formulation process was done for the final compressed bilayer tablet of Mirabegron 25 mg and Silodosin 08 mg compositions. The detailed evaluation values of the all parameters are show in table 7.
Table 7: Analytical results of final bilayer tablet.
Parameters |
Acceptance criteria |
Trial 1 |
Trial 2 |
Trial 3 |
|
Description |
Brick red coloured, round, biconvex, bilayered, film coated tablets, plain on both sides. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
|
Identification |
The retention time of the major peak in the chromatogram of test solution should be corresponds to that the standard solution obtained as directed in the assy. |
Complies |
Complies |
Complies |
|
Average Weight |
346.29 mg to 367.71 mg |
357.65 mg |
356.72 mg |
355.06 mg |
|
Uniformity of weight |
Not more than 2 tablets in 20 deviates from the average weight by more than 5.0%. No tablet deviates from the average weight by more than 10.0%. |
Deviation -2.64 to +2.92% |
Deviation -1.98 to+2.51% |
Deviation -1.61 to +2.64% |
|
Dissolution |
|||||
1st hour Mirabegron EP |
Not more than 30.0% of labeled amount |
Minimum |
8.5% |
12.5% |
1st hour Mirabegron EP |
Maximum |
12.2% |
15.7% |
22.5% |
||
Optimum |
11.1% |
14.0% |
20.4% |
||
3rd hour Mirabegron EP |
25.0 to 65.0% of labeled amount |
Minimum |
32.3% |
38.1% |
3rd hour Mirabegron EP |
Maximum |
38.9% |
44.4% |
47.0% |
||
Optimum |
35.1% |
40.4% |
45.9% |
||
10 hour Mirabegron EP |
Not less than 75.0% of labeled amount |
Minimum |
80.0% |
85.7% |
10 hour Mirabegron EP |
Maximum |
98.8% |
96.2% |
98.8% |
||
Optimum |
90.7% |
90.6% |
93.8% |
||
Silodosin JP |
Not less than 70% (Q) of Labeled amount in 45 minutes |
Minimum |
85.3% |
92.3% |
Silodosin JP |
Maximum |
95.3% |
95.6% |
99.1% |
||
Optimum |
90.3% |
93.9% |
96.3% |
||
Uniformity of Dosage units (By content Uniformity) |
|||||
Mirabegron EP |
Acceptance value should be less than 15 |
9.10 |
11.2 |
5.50 |
|
Silodosin JP |
Acceptance value should be less than 15 |
10.30 |
13.0 |
5.49 |
|
Assay: Each Film coated Bilayer tablet contains: |
|||||
Mirabegron EP (as extended-release form) 50 mg |
90.0 to 110.0% of labelled amount |
103.0% |
103.4% |
102.5% |
|
Silodosin JP 8 mg |
90.0 to 110.0% of labelled amount |
98.4% |
98.1% |
98.3% |
CONCLUSION:
Based on summary report and observed result at different stage, it is concluded that process validation of Mirabegron 25 mg (ER) & Silodosin 8 mg Tablets was carried out as per respective protocol and observed results of critical process parameters and critical quality attributes were found within the specified limit. Finished product results of batch were found within the specified limit.
REFERENCES
Chandan Singh*, Dr. Rita Saini, Dr. Shivanand Patil, A Process Development and Validation of Mirabegron Extended Release 25 Mg and Silodosin 8mg Bilayer Tablet, Int. J. of Pharm. Sci., 2025, Vol 3, Issue 6, 634-643. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15593321