PES Modern College of Pharmacy (For Ladies), Moshi, Pune.
Solubility enhancement of poorly water-soluble drugs remain a significant challenge in pharmaceutical formulation development. Drug solubility is a quite common issue and affects the bioavailability of a drug in the body. Various methods can accommodate to improve solubility of poorly soluble drugs. Hydrotropy is one of the unique technique which can be used to enhance the solubility of poorly water-soluble drugs with many folds by using hydrotropes like sodium citrate, urea, sodium benzoate, etc. Hydrotropes typically contain both a hydrophilic and a hydrophobic component which help to form micelle like structure. Hydrotropic solubilization has emerged as a valuable technique in pharmaceutical formulations, offering a promising solution to enhance the solubility of poorly soluble drugs. This method leverages the ability of hydrotropic agents to disrupt intermolecular interactions between drug molecules, thereby increasing their aqueous solubility. This technique has several advantages like doesn’t require chemical modification of hydrophobic drugs, addition of emulsifying agent, use of minimum organic solvent. This review, mainly focus on hydrotropy, mechanism of hydrotropy and its applications in pharmaceutical formulation.
The preparation of a poorly water-soluble drugs is facing a challenging issue by pharmaceutical industry, and it is expected to increase because around 40% or more of the new chemical substances being generated by drug discovery programs are poorly water-soluble drugs. (1) Orally dispense drugs totally absorb only when they show equitable solubility in gastric environment and such drugs show good bioavailability but other unequitable drugs or API needs to be soluble properly to show good bioavailability. A number of techniques are used to improve solubility of such poorly water-soluble drug and also improve its bioavailability. (2)
Solubility:
Solubility is a property of substances in a particular solvent. In quantitative terms it is concentration of dissolved solute in a saturated solution at a specific temperature. It is measured as maximum amount of solute dissolved in an appropriate solvent equilibrium. (3) Solubility is an important parameter to attain desired concentration of the drug to show specified pharmacological response.(4) The solubility of drug can be expressed as percentage, parts, molality, molarity, mole fraction and volume fraction. (5) The solubility of the drug in water is a fundamental attribute that must be scrutinized. The pharmacokinetic outline is dominant, especially for drugs with low solubility. Most of the BCS class II drugs has poor aqueous solubility and also high permeability. Biopharmaceutical Classification system was invented by the United state Food and Drug Administration. It helps to distinguish drug into four classes according to permeability and solubility. Solubility obstacles are mostly look forward in the Class II and Class IV of the Biopharmaceutical classification system facing dissolution as the rate limiting factor for absorption of drug due to low solubility. (3)
The descriptive solubility terms are noted in Table 1.
Table 1: Expression for approximate solubility (3)
Descriptive terms |
Relative amounts of solvents to dissolve 1 parts of solute |
Very soluble |
<1 |
Freely soluble |
From 1 -10 |
Soluble |
From 10 -30 |
Sparingly soluble |
From 30 -100 |
Slightly soluble |
From 100 -1000 |
Very slightly soluble |
From 1000 -10000 |
Insoluble or practically insoluble |
>10000 |
There are different techniques introduced for enhancing solubility of the poorly water-soluble drugs such as hydrotropy, solid dispersion, PH modification, co-solvency, co-crystallization, Cyclodextrin complexation, Dendrimers, Nano- suspensions, Self emulsifying drug delivery system.
Hydrotrope:
Carl Neuburg was the first scientist to describe the term hydrotropic agents in 1916. It explains the rise in the solubility of the solute by adding equitably high concentration of salts of alkali metals of different organic acids. Hydrotrope is a mixture which has fundamental formation of a hydrophilic part and hydrophobic part. (6) In comparison to surfactants, they contain too small hydrophobic fraction. The competence of Hydrotrope solubilization technique relay upon the equilibrium between hydrophobic and hydrophilic part of Hydrotrope. Hydrotrope is a chemical that dissolves hydrophobic substances in aqueous solutions. Hydrotropes typically contain both a hydrophilic and a hydrophobic component (surfactants), but the hydrophobic component is usually too tiny to induce spontaneous self-aggregation. Hydrotropes have an ideal concentration above which self-aggregation 'suddenly' begins (as observed in micelle- and vesicle-forming surfactants, that, although a not necessarily anionic, can act as a hydrotropic agent, CMC and CVC, respectively). However, particular hydrotropes self-aggregate in stages, progressively enhancing agglomeration size. Still, several hydrotropes are unable to self-aggregate unless a solubilizer is added.
Hydrotropy:
Hydrotropy is a solubilization procedure in which an addition of significant quantities of a second substance increases the water-based dissolution of another solute. The solute comprises of salts of alkali metals with different organic acids. Hydrotropic agents are referred to as ionic organic salts. Chemical compounds or salts that improve the solubility of an individual medium are referred to as "salt in" the solute, whereas salts that decrease the solubility are referred to "salt out". Various salts possessing big anions or cations that are especially soluble in water cause the "salting in" of non-electrolytes called "hydrotropic salts," a phenomenon termed "hydrotropism." Hydrotropic solutions do not exhibit colloidal features and have a minimal contact with both the hydrotropic substance with the solute. Hydrotropy refers to an enhancement of solubility for water caused by adding a significant quantity of chemicals. The method by which it increases dissolvability is much more closely connected to complexation, which involves a weak contact with hydrotropic agents such as sodium benzoate, sodium acetate, sodium alginate, and urea and weakly soluble medicines. (7)
Mechanism of Hydrotrope:
Hydrotrope enhances water solubility by molecular self-association and the binding of hydrotrope particles to the solute. Despite their widespread application in a variety of industrial sectors, little is known about the mechanisms underlying hydrotropism. Several hypotheses and investigations are being conducted to clarify the processes of hydrotrope. Three approaches exist for reducing the available proposed mechanisms:
1. Self-aggregation potential
2. Structure breakers and structure makers
3. Ability to produce micelles-like structures.
1.Self-Aggregation Potential:
The minimum hydrotropic concentration (MHC) is the critical concentration for hydrotrope molecules to aggregate, indicating their self-aggregation potential. Hydrotropic agents' solubilization capacity depends on their hydrophilic-lipophilic characteristics and the solute particle composition. Hydrotropes have volume-fraction-dependent solubilization potential. Initially, hydrotrope molecules establish a pairwise initial association, which is followed by successive stages to produce trimers, tetramers, and so on, and these complexes (trimers, tetramers) may lead to greater water solubility. These findings were derived via fluorescence emission methods, crystallographic analysis, molecular dynamics replication, and thermodynamic solubility studies. Aside these, they can also act as bridging agents, lowering the Gibbs energy and increasing the dissolution of a solute. Simply put, the composition of the hydrotrope-water combination around the drug molecule holds the key for comprehending the basis of the self-aggregation capacity.
Diagrammatic representation of mechanism of hydrotropy: Hydrotropic agents with planar hydrophobic part and hydrophilic part.
Fig.1 Mechanism of hydrotrope
2. Structure-breakers and Structure-maker:
In hydrotropic solubilization procedure, an electrostatic charge of the donor-acceptor atom has a critical function; thus, they are also referred to as a structure-breaker. Hydrotropic compounds, such as urea, increase solubility by affecting the solvent's capacity to build structures via hydrogen bonding between molecules. Structure-breaker hydrotropes (chaotropes) and structure-maker hydrotropes (kosmotropes) affect solubility in various ways. Kosmotropes diminish the critical micelle concentration (CMC) by strengthening hydrophobic interactions, resulting in larger micelles and less hydration.
3.Ability to Form Micelle-like Structures:
Hydrotropes can increase solubility by generating micelle-like structures through self-association with solutes. This lowers the electrostatic repulsion between solute molecules. Examples include alkyl-benzene sulfonates, alkyl sulphates, lower alkanoates and aromatic anionic hydrotropes such as nicotinamide and sodium salicylate. Aromatic anionic hydrotropic compounds, like nicotinamide, boost the dissolving ability of riboflavin by a self-association mechanism, resulting in micellar formations. In contrast, anionic hydrotropes such as sodium salicylate enhance the solubility of poorly water-soluble chemicals such as phenazopyridine (PMZ) by producing stable, mixed micelles. This mixed micellization lowers electrostatic repulsion between PMZ's head groups, enhancing its solubility.(8–10)
Mixed hydrotropy:
Mixed hydrotropic solubilization method is the phenomenon that enhances the solubility of poorly water-soluble medications in the mixture of hydrotropic agents, which can give incredible synergistic enhancement impacts on the solubility of weakly water-soluble substances, utilization of it in the formulation of certain dosage forms of water insoluble drugs, and to minimize the concentration of individual hydrotropic agent to reduce the adverse effects instead of using an excessive amount of one hydrotrope, a combination of, say, five hydrotropes can be used in 1/5th concentrations, lowering their individual toxicities. (8)
Advantages of Mixed Hydrotropic Solubilization:
Pharmaceutical applications of hydrotropic solubilization:
1. Enhance bioavailability: By increasing the solubility of poorly soluble drugs, hydrotropic agents can improve their absorption and bioavailability.
2. Improve formulation flexibility: Hydrotropic solubilization enables the development of various formulations, including tablets, capsules, and injectables.
3. Reduce toxicity: By enhancing solubility, hydrotropic agents can help reduce the toxicity associated with poorly soluble drugs.
4. Facilitate drug delivery: Hydrotropic solubilization can aid in the design of targeted drug delivery systems, enabling more efficient and effective treatment outcomes.
5. Improved sensitivity and accuracy: Hydrotropic solubilization enables the accurate determination of poorly water-soluble drugs, even at low concentrations.
6. Reduced interference: Hydrotropic solubilization can reduce interference from excipients and other components, enabling the accurate determination of the active pharmaceutical ingredient. (11)
7. Quantitative estimation by spectrophotometry: Poorly water-soluble drugs can be easily analyzed by using spectrophotometric analysis in hydrotropic solubilization such as Rosiglitazone, cephalexin, etc. (12,13)
8. Quantitative estimation by titrimetric analysis: Poorly water-soluble drugs can be easily analyzed by using titrimetric analysis in hydrotropic solubilization such as ibuprofen, flurbiprofen and naproxen using sodium benzoate. (14)
9. Preparation of hydrotropic solid dispersions of poorly water- soluble drugs precluding the use of organic solvents. Such as felodipine using poly-ethylene glycol 6000 and poly-vinyl alcohol. (15)
Table 2: Different hydrotropic solubilization studies for various poorly water-soluble drug with respect to formulation development
Sr. No |
Drug |
Hydrotropic agents |
Outcome |
Reference |
1 |
Lurasidone Hydrochloride |
Nicotinamide, Sodium benzoate, Sodium Citrate |
Immediate dissolution of insoluble drug Lurasidone Hydrochloride in the aqueous dissolution media |
(16) |
2 |
Naproxen |
0.5% ibuprofen sodium solution |
350 times improvement in aqueous solubility |
(17) |
3 |
Aceclofenac |
Urea 20% & sodium citrate 10% |
Improvement in vitro dissolution. Improved in solubility more than 250 folds |
(18) |
4 |
Mefenamic Acid |
PEG 4000 |
Enhance the release of low soluble drugs from its dosage form |
(19) |
5 |
Furosemide |
15:20:5 Urea, Sodium Benzoate, Sodium citrate |
Improvement in the solubility of furosemide |
(20) |
6 |
Griseofulvin |
Trisodium citrate, urea, sodium acetate, sodium benzoate, sodium salicylates |
Solubility and dissolution enhancement of poor water-soluble drugs. |
(21) |
7 |
Nevirapine |
Citric acid 10% & urea 20% |
Enhancement in solubility of nevirapine |
(22) |
8 |
Telmisartan |
5.0 M urea solution &1.0 M citric acid solution |
15737 folds improve solubility |
(23) |
9 |
Dexamethasone |
Sodium benzoate and sodium Salicylate |
Improvement in the Solubility of Dexamethasone |
(24) |
10 |
Cefprozil |
Potassium acetate, Potassium citrate, Sodium acetate, Sodium citrate, Urea |
Solubilization of cepfrozil enhances by using different hydrotropic agents |
(25) |
11 |
Chartreusin |
Hydroxybenzoate |
Aqueous solubility of water insoluble cytotoxic agent, chartreusin, increased at PH 7 by using hydroxybenzoate as a hydrotropic agent. |
(26) |
12 |
Zaltoprofen |
Urea, sodium benzoate |
Improved in solubility more than 600-fold |
(27) |
13 |
Aceclofenac |
0.5 M Ibuprofen Sodium |
Improvement in solubility of Aceclofenac |
(28) |
14 |
Riboflavin |
Caffeine & Nicotinamide |
Two hydrotropic agents lead to increase in the solubility of vitamin |
(29) |
15 |
Etodolac |
Sodium benzoate, Sodium acetate |
sodium benzoate and sodium acetate were found to be more stable |
(30) |
16 |
Nimesulide |
Piperazine, sodium benzoate, Sodium Ascorbate, Sodium Salicylate |
Improved in solubility using piperazine as Hydrotrope was developed |
(31) |
17 |
Ofloxacin |
Sodium citrate, sodium benzoate, urea, Sodium Acetate, Niacinamide, Lignocaine HCL, PEG 6000, PEG 400 |
Aqueous injection of drug was prepared for antimicrobial effectiveness and stability |
(32) |
18 |
Halofantrine |
Caffeine, nicotinamide |
Solubility is increased to a greater extent in the presence of caffeine |
(33) |
19 |
Ibuprofen |
Sodium acetate, Sodium benzoate, Sodium toluene sulfonate, Sodium salicylate and Sodium toluate |
Improvement in solubility of Ibuprofen by using various hydrotropes. sodium benzoate was more powerful Hydrotrope |
(34) |
20 |
Ketoprofen |
2.0 M Potassium Acetate |
Enhance the solubility of Ketoprofen using hydrotopic Agent |
(35) |
21 |
Naproxen |
Niacinamide |
The solubility of Naproxen using Niacinamide solution was more than 110 fold |
(36) |
22 |
Piroxicam |
Ibuprofen sodium |
The solubility of piroxicam using Ibuprofen sodium was more than 50 folds |
(34) |
23 |
Olanzipine |
Sodium benzoate, sodium acetate, sodium bicarbonate, sodium chloride, sodium gluconate, thiourea, trisodium citrate, Urea |
Enhance solubility of drug using hydrotopic agents was more than 6, 19, 22, 74, 12, 89, 59 % 98 folds |
(37) |
24 |
Lornoxicam and Paracetamol |
Urea |
Enhance solubility of Lornoxicam and paracetamol |
(38) |
25 |
Theophyllin |
7.5 M Sodium Salicylate & 5.5 M Resorcinol |
2 fold increase in solubility with respect to the sodium salicylate and 1.3 fold increase in the solubility with respect to the Resorcinol |
(39) |
26 |
Sparfloxacin |
Sodium Benzoate |
Enhancement in the solubility of Sparfloxacin |
(40) |
27 |
Glipizide |
tri-sodium citrate and urea solution |
Hydrotropic solubilization is an effective technique in the enhancement of solubility of Glipizide |
(41) |
28 |
Escitalopram |
Niacinamide |
Improvement in solubility of Escitalopram using Hydrotrope |
(42) |
29 |
Chlorobenzene |
Citric acid, sodium benzoate and urea |
Solubility of chlorobenzene increases 53.98 times in the presence of urea as hydrotrope |
(43) |
30 |
L-Tyrosine |
Caffeine, Nicotinamide, Sodium salicylate and Sodium Benzoate |
Solubility of L-Tyrosine increases with increase in Hydrotrope concentration and varying temperature |
(44) |
31 |
Amino-nitrobenzene |
Sodium benzoate, sodium saccharin, dimethyl benzamide |
Solubility of amino-nitrobenzene increases with increase in concentration of hydrotrope |
(45) |
32 |
Methyl benzoate |
Citric acid, urea and nicotinamide |
Increase the solubility of methyl benzoate by 26.66 times in the presence of citric acid. |
(46) |
33 |
Furfural |
Urea, tri-sodium citrate, sodium toluate and sodium benzoate |
Solubility of furfural has been increased in the existence of urea |
(47) |
34 |
Acetylsalicylic acid |
Sodium salicylate, sodium benzoate, nicotinamide and urea |
Hydrotropic agents enhance the solubility of Acetylsalicylic acid |
(48) |
35 |
m/p-Amino-acetophenone |
Diethyl nicotinamide, sodium pseudocumene sulfonate and sodium thiocynate |
Sodium thiocynate was identified to be a best hydrotrope for enhancement of solubility of m/p Amino acetophenone |
(49) |
36 |
Hydro-chlorothiazide |
niacinamide, sodium acetate, sodium benzoate, sodium citrate and urea |
There was enhancement in solubility of hydrochlorothiazide in hydrotropic solution |
(50) |
37 |
Gatifloxacin |
2 M sodium benzoate solution and 1.5 M metformin hydrochloride solution. |
Solubility of gatifloxacin in 2 M sodium benzoate solution was more than 230 times and in 1.5 M metformin hydrochloride solution was more than 18-fold as contrasted to solubility in the distilled water. |
(51) |
38 |
Carbamazepine |
urea and nicotinamide |
By using either urea or nicotinamide as a hydrotropic agent, solubility of the carbamazepine can dramatically increase. |
(52) |
39 |
Glipizide |
Sodium acetate, Sodium Benzoate and salicylate |
Enhancement in the solubility of glipizide |
(53) |
40 |
Lornoxicam |
2M sodium benzoate |
Enhancement in the solubility of Lornoxicam |
(54) |
41 |
empagliflozin |
Ammonium acetate and sodium citrate |
Successful development and validation of a method of assessment of empagliflozin using hydrotopic phenomenon |
(55) |
42 |
Meloxicam |
Sodium Benzoate |
Significant enhancement in solubility with the highest increment of sodium benzoate |
(56) |
43 |
Ezetimibe |
2M Ammonium Acetate & 2M Sod. Citrate |
Enhancement of solubility of Ezetimibe by hydrotopic agents |
(57) |
44 |
Diacerein |
Sodium Acetate |
Enhancement in the solubility of Diacerein |
(58) |
46 |
Rosuvastatin calcium |
Sodium Benzoate, urea, Mannitol, Sodium Salicylate |
Sodium Citrate is useful to enhance the solubility of Rosuvastatin |
(59) |
CONCLUSION
This study concludes that solubility is the most essential physical attribute of a medicine for bioavailability, formulation, the development of multiple dosage forms for various drugs, and quantitative analysis. Solubility can be increased by numerous approaches, among which hydrotropy is highly important. To overcome solubility constraints, numerous enhancing techniques are employed, with hydrotropy being the most important. Hydrotropy is the use of hydrotropic chemicals that self-assemble with poorly soluble medications, increasing solubility and simplifying formulation development. The advantages of hydrotropes have been demonstrated in numerous disciplines because of their exceptional characteristics such as water solubilization, that makes it a better solvent, inflammability, which at first eliminates any risk, and high electrical conductivity, leading to greater acceptability. However, there are still many more issues that must be addressed. As a result, it is suggested that the value of hydrotropes be investigated in order to anticipate improved drug administration of poorly water-soluble pharmaceuticals and drug moieties with limiting therapeutic applications, as well as to explain their successful structure-based mechanism. ((8,60)
REFERENCES
Snehal Kashid, Purva Katore, Madhavi Tirkhunde, Rutuja Thorat, Harshada Padwal*, Dr. Vrushali Tambe, A Review on Solubility Enhancement of Poorly Soluble Drugs by Using Hydrotrophic Agents, Int. J. of Pharm. Sci., 2025, Vol 3, Issue 3, 2797-2808 https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15099654